Friday, January 04, 2013

Release: Attorney General Cuccinelli announces legal victory against EPA attempt to regulate water itself as a pollutant

State Seal
Commonwealth of Virginia
Office of the Attorney General

name and titleaddress



For media inquiries only, contact: Brian J. Gottstein
Email: bgottstein@oag.state.va.us (best contact method)
Phone: 804-786-5874



Attorney General Cuccinelli announces legal victory against EPA attempt to regulate water itself as a pollutant


- Victory will save Virginia taxpayers estimated $300 million plus -

RICHMOND (January 3, 2013) - Late this afternoon, a federal judge accepted arguments made by Attorney General Ken Cuccinelli and ruled that the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency has exceeded its authority by attempting to regulate water itself as a pollutant by imposing restrictions on the flow of stormwater into Fairfax County's Accotink Creek. The effect of this ruling could save Virginia taxpayers more than $300 million in unnecessary costs.

EPA had previously issued an edict that would cut the flow of water into the creek by nearly half, in an effort to address the sediment flow on the bottom of the creek. In regulating the flow rate of stormwater into the creek, the agency was trying to regulate water itself as a pollutant, rather than the sediment. The attorney general challenged the EPA's action as exceeding the agency's legal authority to regulate pollutants under the Clean Water Act (CWA). These restrictions also would have diverted public funds that could be spent more effectively on stream restoration for Accotink Creek and other waterways in the region.

Judge Liam O'Grady agreed with co-plaintiffs VDOT (represented by the attorney general) and Fairfax County, saying in his ruling that federal law simply does not grant EPA the authority it claims. The Clean Water Act gives the EPA the authority to establish TMDLs - Total Maximum Daily Loads - regulating maximum acceptable levels of pollutants that may be discharged on a daily basis into a particular waterway. The problem for the EPA is that water is not a pollutant under the CWA. "The Court sees no ambiguity in the wording of [the federal Clean Water Act]. EPA is charged with establishing TMDLs for the appropriate pollutants; that does not give them the authority to regulate nonpollutants," O'Grady said.

"EPA's thinking here was that if Congress didn't explicitly prohibit the agency from doing something, that meant it could, in fact, do it," said Cuccinelli. "Logic like that would lead the EPA to conclude that if Congress didn't prohibit it from invading Mexico, it had the authority to invade Mexico. This incredibly flawed thinking would have allowed the agency to dramatically expand its power at its own unlimited discretion. Today, the court said otherwise."

EPA also claimed that it could regulate water flow because it was a surrogate measure for regulating sediment. To that argument, Judge O'Grady responded, "EPA may not regulate something over which it has no statutorily granted power... as a proxy for something over which it is granted power." He continued, "If the sediment levels in Accotink Creek have become dangerously high, what better way to address the problem than by limiting the amount of sediment permitted in the creek?"

"Stormwater runoff is not a pollutant, so EPA is not authorized to regulate it," O'Grady said.

"EPA was literally treating water itself--the very substance the Clean Water Act was created to protect--as a pollutant," the attorney general noted. "This EPA mandate would have been expensive, cumbersome, and incredibly difficult to implement. And it was likely to do more harm than good, as its effectiveness was unproven and it would have diverted hundreds of millions of dollars Fairfax County was already targeting for more effective methods of sediment control."

On December 14, 2012, the attorney general personally argued in federal district court in Alexandria on behalf of the Virginia Department of Transportation, and was joined by the Fairfax County Board of Supervisors, against the EPA's overreaching restrictions. The attorney general challenged this substantial expansion of EPA's regulatory power as a departure from the EPA's CWA-authorized role of establishingTMDL requirements. VDOT and Fairfax County initiated this litigation in July 2012.

A copy of the court's opinion can be found here.

More about Attorney General Cuccinelli

Photos of the attorney general

A copy of this news release may be found on the attorney general's web site here.

Mike Lee: Everything About Fiscal Cliff Deal a Failure, Only Had Six Minutes to Read It Before Voting

Mike Lee: Everything About Fiscal Cliff Deal a Failure, Only Had Six Minutes to Read It Before Voting

New Year Welcomes New Vision for Combined Joint Task Force-Horn of Africa

Navy Encourages Sailors to be Proactive with Perform to Serve

Sailors Train for Navy's Visit, Board, Search, and Seizure Teams

Wednesday, January 02, 2013

Kate Winslet Receives Ticket to Space

Kate Winslet Receives Ticket to Space: Kate Winslet will blast off to space thanks to a $200,000 ticket gifted to the actress from Sir Richard Branson. According to the Daily Telegraph, the actress, who recently married Branson’s nephew Ned RocknRoll, received the out-of-this-world ticket from Branson as a thank you for...

China eyes greater market share for its GPS rival | Defense Technology News at DefenceTalk

China eyes greater market share for its GPS rival | Defense Technology News at DefenceTalk

Scott Brown prods Ed Markey on Massachusetts residency - Bobby Cervantes - POLITICO.com

Scott Brown prods Ed Markey on Massachusetts residency - Bobby Cervantes - POLITICO.com

India To Acquire More Coastal Surveillance Radars, Offshore Patrol Vessels

India To Acquire More Coastal Surveillance Radars, Offshore Patrol Vessels

War of 1812 Dick Morris TV: Lunch ALERT!

MacIver Institute: Rep. Vos Talks 2013 Session


The Coolest Naval Victory in US History Dick Morris TV: Lunch ALERT!

Press Release - Assembly Republicans: Mining Reform Top Priority

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE January 2, 2013
FOR MORE INFORMATION PLEASE CONTACT:

SPEAKER-ELECT ROBIN VOS 608-266-3387
MAJORITY LEADER SCOTT SUDER 608-266-2401


 
Assembly Republicans: Mining Reform Top Priority


MADISON… Speaker-elect Robin Vos (R-Rochester) and Majority Leader Scott Suder (R-Abbottsford) announced the first bill they will introduce in the 2013-2014 session will be legislation to reform the outdated mining laws in Wisconsin.
Mining reform is a top priority in the state Assembly,” said Speaker-elect Vos. “I’m hopeful all the interested parties can come together to protect our environment and make mining reform happen.”

"Our state has a rich history of mining," said Majority Leader Suder. "Democrats and Republicans agree we should update our mining laws to hopefully bring a new mine and thousands of jobs to Wisconsin."


Assembly Republicans are joining Governor Walker today during his visits to companies that could benefit from a new iron ore mine in Wisconsin. The “Mining for Jobs” tour includes stops in Green Bay, Schofield and Milwaukee.

"Today we have the opportunity to show the citizens of Wisconsin that mining reform could have a large economic impact not only in northern Wisconsin but also throughout the state," said Majority Leader Suder.

A study from NorthStar Economics, Inc. revealed a new iron ore mine in northern Wisconsin could generate a $2 billion economic impact for the state of Wisconsin. This includes $20.6 million state and local tax revenue over the two-year construction process and a $604 million annual economic impact once operational.

The study also found that thousands of new jobs could be created from a new mining operation. More than 2,800 total long-term jobs would be generated with 700 direct mining positions and 2,100 support positions.

“It would irresponsible to ignore this great opportunity for job creation," said Speaker-elect Vos. “I look forward to working with my colleagues on both sides of the aisle to finally bring mining reform to Wisconsin.” 
The 2013-2014 legislative session officially begins Monday, January 7th.


-###-

Sen. Toomey: GOP should risk shutdown to force spending cuts in debt-limit fight - The Hill's Blog Briefing Room

Sen. Toomey: GOP should risk shutdown to force spending cuts in debt-limit fight - The Hill's Blog Briefing Room

MacIver Institute: Sen. Fitzgerald Talks 2013 Session

President Obama Returns to Hawaii Vacation Post-Cliff Deal

President Obama Returns to Hawaii Vacation Post-Cliff Deal: Less than an hour after Congress and the White House resolved the fiscal cliff, President Obama boarded Air Force One to return to his planned Hawaiian holiday vacation. He boarded the plane at Joint Base Andrews in Camp Springs, Md., shortly before midnight Wednesday following...

USA: Raytheon Lands USD 169 Million DDG Contract Naval Today

USA: Raytheon Lands USD 169 Million DDG Contract Naval Today

MacIver Institute: Wisconsin Legislature Targets GAB

Pope prays with 40,000 Christian youths at St. Peter's Square

Fiscal Cliff Deal Raises Taxes, Delays Sequestration...And Will Cut Spending!

Fiscal Cliff Deal Raises Taxes, Delays Sequestration...And Will Cut Spending!

China adds destroyers to marine surveillance: report | Navy & Maritime Security News at DefenceTalk

China adds destroyers to marine surveillance: report | Navy & Maritime Security News at DefenceTalk